« To The Point
Pastors Persecuted in Pakistan, China & Cuba »

March 13, 2006

The myth of Chinese religious freedom

A very interesting news item went up on the VOM web site late Friday afternoon.  The information, which came to VOM through our partnership with China Aid Association, told of a Chinese police raid on a church in Henan Province, China.

Here's the interesting thing: the church that was raided was REGISTERED WITH THE GOVERNMENT.  It was a member of the Three Self Patriotic Movement.  It had government permission to exist!

There are those in America who believe the myth of Chinese religious freedom. They believe that Chinese Christians are as free as American Christians.  They see church registration in China no differently than a church in the U.S. registering for tax-exempt status.  In the minds of these Communist apologists, persecuted Christians in China are trouble makers and law breakers; if they would learn to cooperate with government leaders and abide by the law, then their troubles would be over.

This case blows the apologists' position out of the water.  If registration is the answer for Chinese Christians, then why was a registered church raided by police?

Seems this church violated the Chinese "Three Designate" policy. All three of the "designates" in this policy are controlled by the government: they designate WHO can lead a religious service; they designate WHERE such services can be held; and they designate WHEN the services can be. And the OK to lead meetings is location-specific.  If a pastor wants to preach at a church in the next county, he or she has to get government permission to do so.

Seems in this case either the pastor leading the Bible study session didn't have permission to minister in Xiangcheng County, or the church didn't have permission to hold a meeting on a Monday morning.  Or both.  Pastor Liu Tuanjie, age 34, is from Shangshui County, though he was leading this meeting in Xiangcheng.  He was one of three leaders arrested by the police when they raided the meeting.

Has your church had a guest speaker lately? Did you get permission from the local police, or even from denominational headquarters? Was your guest speaker required to present his or her identification at the police station before speaking, and maybe to run the sermon outline by the police chief or mayor for a stamp of approval?

Religious freedom in China exists only for those who are Communists first, and Christians (or Muslims, or Falun Gong, or whatever) after that. Chinese church registration isn't just getting along with the government, and it is NOTHING like tax-exempt registration in the U.S.

It's time for American Christians, even the China apologists, to know the truth.

Todd Nettleton is the Director of News Services for The Voice of the Martyrs-USA.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The myth of Chinese religious freedom:



What a powerful post. I especially found your questions at the end very thought provoking. Thank you for alerting all of us to the reality of what happens to those in countries that are not free. We need to keep praying!

Todd thank you for this information. I have read of the persecution in China and we should be praying for our brothers and sisters there on a daily basis! Have you heard any news lately regarding Brother Yun?

I fear for the safety of all Christians in china now even more than before. With this sudden relaxation of the 50 years of persecution by appointing a Catholic Bishop, many Christians will feel it is their duty to stand for their beliefs. True as this is, they should be aware that this ploy by the present regine may be nothing more than an attempt to identify as many Christians as possible in order to irradicate a threat that would not go away. Their Faith is about to be tested to its reward

The comments to this entry are closed.